
First Analysing
Top of the pops magazine has inspired me the most; this is because I like the, layout, style, images and the fun of the magazine. I also like the age group that it’s based for, you can have a lot of fun with it. Top of the Pops magazine is monthly published. It features chart information, star gossip, fashion and beauty advice, quizzes, song lyrics and posters. It is an additional magazine for the TV show Top of the Pops. The magazine was launched in 1995 along with the show, which has now been cancelled however the magazine is still being published.
The main thing that stands out to me about this magazine is their colour scheme and fonts they've used, they've used 3 simple colours; white, pink and purple sparkle, this has made the presentation towards the page more eye catching and exciting, which I think works really well with their choice of fonts, they've used fonts that are quite free-flowing and elegant rather than bold and blunt, I think it works well with the target audience of young girls too, it's not so much a boys theme.
Their use of images works really well, they have a lot of images on their front page, but not loads so that it completely takes over and looks bad. Their main picture is most effective, Zac Efron is a big sex appeal to young girls so if they see him on the front cover of the magazine they'll want their parents to buy it for them, on the same subject, they use High School Musical as their theme so there is a bit of relevance to the other images too.
Another thing that stands out which is relevant to the age range, is the picture, the main thing that is seen when a magazine is picked up is the image as it is always the biggest part. The objects that make this picture stand out so much is the sparkles that cover the image. I think this is a really effective device to use. From the research that I done prior, the age range/gender of this magazine is 11-15 year old girls, so everything they have done/used has made the whole thing relevant towards them.

Second Analysing
I did not find the Smash Hits magazine quite as interesting or exciting as the Top of the Pops magazine, I think this is because it has a dull, ordinary colour scheme, it uses again 3 main colours, black, yellow and white, yet these aren't are interesting or as effective. I think this is because this magazine is more of a uni-sex magazine, it's not like Top of the Pops who is mainly targeted at girls, but has an equal interest from both genders. It's not 100% clear what the name of the magazine is because it is covered by the singer, but this could also be quite effective, it's effective because the magazine is a well known magazine that has been around for years that people will know what it is and would be able to tell by the style which magazine it is. The main thing that stands out is the phrase in the centre of the image reading; "SON OF DORK" I think this is only relevant if you know what they're talking about, to some people the word 'DORK' might just mean a rude offensive word, but to people of that generation and stereotypes that would be relevant and they may understand more.
I think the Top of the Pops magazine is presented a lot better than the Smash Hits magazine, to me it looks like Smash hits haven't really thought there design through, everything just seems so bold and blunt, where as with Top of the Pops they make it more smooth flowing and elegant.
Both magazines use strap lines in very different ways, Top of the Pops use theirs in a way which talks a little about each story, where as in the Smash Hits magazine they are simple with what they say, for example they just use the names of artists; Simon Webbe. Rihanna. They don't go into any detail about them at all.